New York City Pizza Shelter Cove (Menu)
28 Shelter Cove Ln, Coastal South Carolina
+1 843-785-4200
Popular Items
Double Dish
7.99
Single Dish
5.99
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
16.99
Kilwins Tracks
16.99
Single Cake Cone
5.99
Fudge Bundle!
23.99
Marshmallow S'mores
16.99
Sea-Salt Caramel
16.99
Mint Chocolate Chip
16.99
Cake Batter
16.99
Shelter Cove Favorites
12oz Bag of Salt Water Taffy
11.99
Ice Cream! (scoops)
Double Cake Cone
7.99
Double Dish
7.99
Single Cake Cone
5.99
Single Dish
5.99
Toppings/Add ons
Chocolate Sprinkles (for 1)
0.49
Hot Caramel (for 1)
0.99
Hot Fudge (for 1)
0.99
Rainbow Sprinkles (for 1)
0.49
Waffle Bowl
0.99
Waffle Cone
0.99
Ice Cream! (quarts)
All-American Two-Berry Pie
16.99
Banana Fudge Pie
16.99
Blue Moon
16.99
Blueberry Waffle Cone
16.99
Butter Pecan
16.99
Cake Batter
16.99
Cappuccino Chocolate Chip
16.99
Chocolate
16.99
Chocolate Chip
16.99
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough
16.99
Chocolate Peanut Butter
16.99
Cookies & Cream
16.99
Fudgie Brownie
16.99
Georgia Peach
16.99
Key Lime Pie
16.99
Kilwins Mud
16.99
Kilwins Tracks
16.99
Mackinac Island Fudge
16.99
Marshmallow S'mores
16.99
Mint Chocolate Chip
16.99
NSA Caramel Ripple
16.99
New Orleans Praline Pecan
16.99
Old Fashioned Vanilla
16.99
Pistachio
16.99
Rum Raisin
16.99
Sea-Salt Caramel
16.99
Strawberry Chunk
16.99
Superman
16.99
Toasted Coconut
16.99
Traverse City Cherry
16.99
Fudge
Chocolate
9.99
Chocolate Peanut Butter
9.99
Chocolate Pecan
9.99
Cookies & Cream
9.99
Fudge Bundle!
23.99
Our Signature Turtle
9.99
Peanut Butter
9.99
Sea-Salt Caramel
9.99
Corns and Brittles!
16oz Bag of Caramel Corn
11.99
20oz Bag of Peanut Corn
15.99
24oz Bag of Nutcracker Sweet
21.99
5oz Bag of Caramel Corn
6.99
7oz Bag of Peanut Corn
9.99
8oz Bag of Nutcracker Sweets
12.99
Peanut Brittle
11.99
Pecan Brittle
15.99
Chocolates!
10oz Truffle Assortment
31.99
28oz Family Assortment
74.99
42oz Family Assortment
110.99
8oz Dark Chocolate Cashew Tuttles
19.99
8oz Dark Chocolate Pecan Tuttles
19.99
8oz Milk Chocolate Cashew Tuttles
19.99
8oz Milk Chocolate Pecan Tuttles
19.99
8oz White Chocolate Macadamia Tuttles
19.99
9oz Family Assortment
27.99
