Peter Pan Diner (Menu)
999 Sunrise Hwy, Bay Shore
+1 631-665-1788
Beverages
Coffee
2.05
Tea
2.05
Decaf Coffee
2.15
Hot Chocolate
2.19
Milk
2.49
Chocolate Milk
2.49
Iced Coffee
2.99
Iced Tea
2.99
Soft Drink
2.99
Breakfast Wraps
3 Scrambled Eggs Wrap
10.99
Eggs and Omelettes
2 Eggs
5.69
2 Eggs with Ham
8.49
2 Eggs with Sausage
8.49
2 Eggs with Bacon
8.99
2 Eggs with Corned Beef Hash
9.29
2 Eggs with Canadian Bacon
8.49
American Cheese Omelette
8.79
Swiss Cheese Omelette
8.79
Mozzarella Cheese Omelette
8.79
Cheddar Cheese Omelette
8.79
Feta Cheese Omelette
9.19
Spanish Omelette
8.59
Western Omelette
8.99
Tomato and Feta Omelette
10.39
Ham Omelette
9.29
Bacon Omelette
9.29
Sausage Omelette
9.29
Ham and Cheese Omelette
10.39
Bacon and Cheese Omelette
10.39
Sausage and Cheese Omelette
10.39
Greek Omelette
10.39
Farmer Omelette
9.29
Mexican Omelette
10.49
Create Your Own Omelette
Create Your Own Omelette
11.29
Peter Pancakes
Pecan Nut Peter Pancakes
9.59
Pecan Nut Short Peter Pancakes
7.59
Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chip Peter Pancakes
9.59
Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chip Short Peter Pancakes
7.59
Cinnamon and Raisin Peter Pancakes
9.59
Cinnamon and Raisin Short Peter Pancakes
7.59
Granola Baked Apple and Cinnamon Pancakes
9.59
Granola Baked Apple and Cinnamon Short Pancakes
7.59
Peter Pancakes Topped with Fresh Fruit
9.59
Short Peter Pancakes Topped with Fresh Fruit
7.59
Cranberry and Walnut Peter Pancakes
9.59
Cranberry and Walnut Short Peter Pancakes
7.59
Banana and Nut Peter Pancakes
9.59
Banana and Nut Short Peter Pancakes
7.59
Blueberry Almond Peter Pancakes
9.59
Blueberry Almond Short Peter Pancakes
7.59
Griddle Specialties
Traditional Pancakes
6.79
Traditional Pancakes with Ham
9.39
Traditional Pancakes with Bacon
9.39
Traditional Pancakes with Sausage
9.39
Traditional Pancakes with Ham and 1 Egg
10.49
Traditional Pancakes Bacon and 1 Egg
10.49
Traditional Pancakes with Sausage and 1 Egg
10.49
Traditional Pancakes with Canadian Bacon
10.59
Short Stack
5.69
Short Stack with Ham
8.49
Short Stack with Bacon
8.49
Short Stack with Sausage
8.49
Short Stack with Ham and 1 Egg
9.59
Short Stack with Bacon and 1 Egg
9.59
Short Stack with Sausage and 1 Egg
9.59
Pancakes Deluxe
12.39
French Toast
6.79
French Toast with Ham
9.39
French Toast with Bacon
9.39
French Toast with Sausage
9.39
French Toast with Ham and 1 Egg
10.49
French Toast with Bacon and 1 Egg
10.49
French Toast with Sausage and 1 Egg
10.49
French Toast with Canadian Bacon
10.59
Short French Toast
5.79
Short French Toast with Ham
8.49
Short French Toast with Bacon
8.49
Short French Toast with Sausage
8.49
Short French Toast with Ham and 1 Egg
9.59
Short French Toast with Bacon and 1 Egg
9.59
Short French Toast with Sausage and 1 Egg
9.59
French Toast Deluxe
12.39
Belgian Waffle
6.89
Belgian Waffle with Ham
9.69
Belgian Waffle with Bacon
9.69
Belgian Waffle with Sausage
9.69
Belgian Waffle with Canadian Bacon
10.79
Belgian Waffle with Fresh Fruit
9.59
Appetizers
Fried Calamari
12.19
Baked Clams
9.49
Chicken Wings
10.39
Chicken Tenders
10.39
Mozzarella Sticks
9.89
Potato Skins
8.29
Spinach Pie
8.49
Cheese Quesadilla
8.59
Stuffed Mushrooms
9.49
Sweet Potato Fries
5.59
French Fries
4.99
French Fries with Melted Cheese
6.29
Curly Fries
5.59
Onion Rings
5.59
Loaded Nachos
11.59
Tantalizing Salads
Chef's Salad
16.69
Fruit-Aki Salad
14.99
California Salad
11.39
Spinach Salad
12.99
Cobb Salad
16.79
Our Famous Greek Salad
12.99
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
15.99
Grilled Salmon Caesar Salad
18.39
Crispy Chicken Salad
15.99
Santa Fe Cajun Chicken Salad
15.99
Diet Grilled Chicken Breast Plate Salad
11.89
Peter Pan Wraps
Peter Pan Wrap
11.39
The Grill Wrap
11.79
Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap
11.79
New York Wrap
11.79
Famous Tom Turkey Wrap
11.39
Beef Teriyaki Wrap
13.09
Chicken Teriyaki Wrap
13.09
Greek Salad Chicken Wrap
11.79
Basic Wrap
11.39
Mango-Tango Wrap
11.89
Mama Mia Wrap
11.89
Gobble-Gobble Wrap
11.89
Brooklyn Bridge Pastrami Wrap
12.69
Tuscany Wrap
12.29
Paninis
Peter Pan Panini
12.99
Veggie Panini
12.39
Turkey Club Panini
12.99
Black Forest Ham Panini
12.99
Tuscany Panini
12.39
Best Sellers
2 Classic Hot Dogs
6.69
2 Chili Cheese Dogs
7.89
Texas Smoke Sandwich
12.29
Reuben Sandwich
11.79
The New Champ Sandwich
12.99
Meatball Parmigiana Hero
10.49
Black Bean Burrito
10.49
Taco Wrap
11.19
Roman Holiday Quesadilla
14.79
Pepperoni Pizza Fries
8.39
Fruiti-Aki Salad
14.99
Souvlaki
14.59
Chicken Souvlaki
14.59
Gyro
12.99
Chicken Gyro
12.99
Cowboy Burger
10.99
Sliced London Broil Sandwich Deluxe
17.19
Tuna Melt
9.89
Specialty Sandwiches
Grilled Chicken Italian Style Sandwich
11.59
Grilled Chicken American Style Sandwich
11.59
Grilled Chicken Parmigiana Style Sandwich
11.59
Triple Deckers
Sliced Turkey and Bacon Triple Decker
12.29
Chicken Salad and Bacon Triple Decker
12.29
Burger Corner
Jumbo Burger
6.49
Deluxe Jumbo Burger
9.89
Jumbo Cheeseburger with Melted American Cheese
6.89
Deluxe Jumbo Cheeseburger with Melted American Cheese
10.29
Jumbo Cheeseburger with Swiss
7.39
Deluxe Jumbo Cheeseburger with Swiss
10.79
Jumbo Cheeseburger with Cheddar
7.39
Deluxe Jumbo Cheeseburger with Cheddar
10.79
Jumbo Cheeseburger with Mozzarella
7.39
Deluxe Jumbo Cheeseburger with Mozzarella
10.79
Jumbo Burger with Bacon
7.49
Deluxe Jumbo Burger with Bacon
10.89
Jumbo Burger with Bacon and Melted American Cheese
8.29
Deluxe Jumbo Burger with Bacon and Melted American Cheese
11.69
Jumbo Burger with Bacon and Swiss
8.39
Deluxe Jumbo Burger with Bacon and Swiss
11.79
Jumbo Burger with Bacon and Cheddar
8.39
Deluxe Jumbo Burger with Bacon and Cheddar
11.79
Jumbo Burger with Bacon and Mozzarella
8.39
Deluxe Jumbo Burger with Bacon and Mozzarella
11.79
Specialty Burgers
Cubano Burger
10.99
Cali Burger
10.99
Pattie Melt Burger
10.99
Cowboy Burger
10.99
The Mexi Max Burger
10.99
The Unique Greek Burger
10.99
Siciliano Burger
10.99
Lone Star Chili Cheeseburger
10.99
Call the Fire Department Burger
10.99
Call My Doctor Burger
11.49
Peter Pan's Classic Sliders
9.49
Quesadillas
South of the Border Quesadilla
11.79
Chicken Quesadilla
11.79
Vegetarian Garden of Eatin Quesadilla
12.29
Roman Holiday Quesadilla
14.79
Mediterranean Sunset Quesadilla
13.39
Steak Quesadilla
14.79
Lo-Carb Grilled Chicken Quesadilla
12.29
Lo-Carb Grilled Chicken with Grilled Steak Quesadilla
15.29
Give Cheese a Chance
Ham and Pickle Grilled Cheese Sandwich
10.69
Hot and Spicy Grilled Cheese Sandwich
10.69
Greek Grill Grilled Cheese Sandwich
10.69
Mac and Cheese Grilled Cheese Sandwich
10.69
That's Italian Grilled Cheese Sandwich
10.69
Turkey Club Grilled Cheese Sandwich
10.69
Pizza Pepperoni Grilled Cheese Sandwich
10.69
Gooey Gouda Grilled Cheese Sandwich
10.69
B.L.T.C. Grilled Cheese Sandwich
10.69
Chili Cheddar Grilled Cheese Sandwich
10.69
The Breakfast Cheese Scramble Grilled Cheese Sandwich
10.69
Specialty Selections
Teriyaki Combo
27.59
Key West
23.29
Oriental Sesame Seed Chicken
23.29
Honey Mustard Chicken
23.29
Chicken ala Greco
23.29
Broiled Roumanian Steak and Shrimp Scampi
31.79
Beef and Reef
31.79
Shrimp and Chicken Scampi
26.29
BBQ Ribs and Chicken
20.79
Cereal - Archived
Cereal
3.99
Cereal with Fruit
5.39
Desserts - Archived
Lo-Carb Sugar Free Cheesecake
5.89
Creamy Cheesecake with Fruit
4.69
Fresh Strawberry Cheesecake
5.29
Assorted Layer Cakes
4.69
Strawberry Shortcake
4.69
Carrot Cake
4.69
Pound Cake
3.09
Assorted Fruit Pies
4.39
Assorted Fruit Pie a la Mode
5.69
Lemon Meringue Pie
4.39
Apple Turnover
3.69
Assorted Danish
3.69
Brownie
3.39
Jumbo Cookies
3.09
Creamy Rice Pudding
3.69
Bread Pudding
3.69
Chocolate Pudding
3.69
Jello
2.99
Fruit Cup Assorted Fruit
3.79
Toasted Almond Italian Dessert
5.89
Tiramisu
5.89
Ice Cream
4.79
Rainbow Sherbet
4.79
Chocolate Sundae
7.59
Milk Shake
4.79
Ice Cream Soda
4.79
Egg Cream
3.39
Brownie Sundae
6.99
Banana Split
7.59
Blintzes
12.39
Soup - Archived
Chicken Noodle Soup
5.00
Onion Soup
5.00
Clam Chowder
5.00
Matzoh Ball Soup
5.00
Tomato Basil Soup
5.00
Tomato and Vegetable Soup
5.00
Lentil Soup
5.00
Yankee Bean Soup
5.00
Split Pea Soup
5.00
Seafood Bisque
5.00
Beef Barley Soup
5.00
Cream of Turkey Soup
5.00
